
Terminating Associate Agreements; the dos and don’ts
You may think it is easy to end an associate agreement. However, you would be surprised by how many dental practices get this wrong, often leading to payment of compensation to an associate and hefty legal bills.
In this article we will set out the dos and don’ts to ensure that dental practices and their associates take the right steps when terminating an associate agreement.
Worker or Self-employed?
The employment status of dentists is still a thorny issue. It is often argued before the courts that dentists are in fact ‘workers’ and have employment rights that flow from this.
In any event, regardless of whether the associate is truly self-employed or a worker, then you need to look at the contract and follow the contractual terms when terminating.
However, a worker is protected from termination on the grounds of discrimination or as a result of whistleblowing. Practices are advised to seek legal advice before terminating without notice.
Contractual clauses stating that the associate is self-employed will not help you defend a worker status claim. The question is a factual question based on a legal test, which looks at the reality of the situation not labels. If a disgruntled associate seeks advice on their termination, more often than not we advise them they are a worker and what claims they can pursue as a result.
It is unlikely that the associate will reach the high bar for employee status, but if they did, they would have full employment rights and would be protected from unfair dismissal if they have worked for the practice for over 2 years.
If you are in any doubt; seek legal advice.
Express Contractual Terms
Many contracts will expressly state the notice period the practice and the associate must give to one another to terminate. This is normally three months but can be more. Unless there has been a fundamental breach of contract you must give that amount of notice. Failure by either party to give the correct notice will amount to a breach of contract for which damages can be claimed.
If you want to give the associate less than the stated notice, you will need their agreement to do that.
Your contract may also contain a list of circumstances in which the contract can be terminated with immediate effect, such as being removed from the dental register. You will only be able to terminate without notice if one of those circumstances applies. Again, failure to comply with the contract will amount to a breach by you.
Implied Contractual Terms
Even if your contract does not set out when it can be terminated without notice, it is possible to terminate if the other party is in ‘fundamental breach of contract’.
Failure to pay an associate would be a fundamental breach of contract allowing them to terminate with immediate effect.
You should always seek advice before relying on an alleged fundamental breach. If you are wrong and terminate without cause, you could be sued for failure to give the correct notice.
Common Pitfalls
Here are some common mistakes dental practices make and what you can do to avoid them:
- When an associate gives notice, the practice stops paying them. Payment is a fundamental term of the contract. Unless you have a right to withhold monies for a retention fee you cannot stop paying the associate. The associate could therefore terminate the contract immediately in response to your breach and claim damages for their loss of earnings forthe remaining notice period.
- When disputes arise, some practices arbitrarily withhold pay from associates. Again, an associate would be perfectly entitled to immediately terminate the contract and claim damages for this.
- When an associate gives the correct notice, the practice gives a counter notice ending the contract immediately. If you do not let the associate work their three months, unless they have agreed a shorter notice period, you will be liable for damages for any remaining notice period.
- Relying on spurious allegations to terminate a contract immediately. As stated above, if you do this in error you could be the one facing a claim for damages.
- Despite withholding pay, threatening an associate that if they do not continue to work then the practice will report them to the GDC for failing to ensure patient safety. We are sure our readers would not make such threats, but, this is a common scenario. Associates are fearful of the GDC. However, the GDC are not going to take action against an associate in this situation.
If you would like advice on your current contracts and termination clauses, or need assistance with terminating a contract, please call the team on 0207 388 1658 or email lawyers@jfhlaw.co.uk.
Please note that the information contained in this article was correct at the time of writing. There may have been updates to the law since the article was written which may affect the information and advice given therein.






