
Redundancy Reckoning: What the Wilko Collapse Reveals
Over the past few years, we have seen dramatic changes to the High Street, with many shops that were formally household names closing due to dwindling profits following the Covid-19 pandemic and the public’s increased reliance on on-line shopping. As a result, many people have lost their jobs and have been made redundant.
One of those retail giants was Wilko, who entered administration on 10 August 2023 after rescue talks failed. Eventually, all 400 stores were closed by early October, resulting in the loss of around 12,000–12,500 jobs. Thousands of people were made redundant.
What This Article Covers
In this article, we consider:
- The obligations on businesses to undertake a proper redundancy process
- What can happen when companies don’t keep to the rules
- Planned changes under the new Employment Rights Bill
- What employers need to know moving forward
The Law
The Employment Rights Act provides for two circumstances when redundancy can occur;
- (a) the fact that his employer has ceased or intends to cease
- (b) the fact that the requirements of that business— have ceased or diminished or are expected to cease or diminish.
If an employer plans to dismiss 20 or more employees within a 90-day period, they must initiate collective consultation duties as mandated by the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992.
This process involves engaging with either:
- Elected employee representatives (if employees are not part of a union)
- A recognised trade union
What is meant by consultation?
When contemplating collective redundancies, it is imperative for employers to engage in a constructive consultation process with employee representatives.
This consultation serves as an opportunity for meaningful dialogue between the organisation and its employees regarding:
- The proposed changes
- The rationale for each employee’s potential redundancy
What went wrong with Wilko?
Wilko, a respected high-street retailer, entered administration in August 2023, putting the jobs of approximately 10,000 employees at risk of redundancy.
As the situation developed, it became clear that large-scale layoffs were likely to occur. However, Wilko did not fully meet its legal obligations.
Specifically:
- The company allowed only 45 days for staff consultation
- The required period was 90 days
This oversight limited employees’ opportunities to engage in the process, hindering their ability to understand, question, and respond to the proposed redundancies.
As a result of Wilko’s actions, the GMB trade union filed a claim on behalf of the 10,000 dissatisfied employees.
Tribunal’s Findings
The GMB’s claim stated that Wilko had not met its obligations for collective consultation.
The Employment Tribunal agreed, finding that Wilko violated its legal responsibilities by failing to conduct timely and effective collective consultations prior to implementing mass redundancies in 2023.
The Tribunal highlighted that:
- Entering administration does not remove legal obligations
- Financial difficulty does not exempt employers from consultation duties
These obligations remain enforceable regardless of the company’s economic status.
Financial Consequences
Due to Wilko’s failure to conduct proper consultations:
- Nearly 10,000 workers received a protective pay-out
- The total amounted to £2 million
Breakdown:
- Around 9,000 retail staff received 4 days’ pay each
- Admin support staff received 13 days’ pay
Protecting Your Business During Restructuring
Businesses should:
- Work collaboratively with employees
- Keep detailed records of all consultation communications
- Engage with trade unions where applicable
- Assist in electing employee representatives where no union exists
Taking these steps can help ensure compliance and reduce legal risk.
The Employment Rights Bill (ERB): What Will It Change?
The Employment Rights Bill proposes several key changes:
Increased Protective Awards
- Maximum protective award to increase from 90 to 180 days’ gross pay
Changes to ‘Establishment’
- Currently, separate branches may be treated as separate establishments
- Under the ERB, redundancy thresholds may apply across multiple locations
This means:
- Collective consultation obligations could apply more broadly
- Employers must consider total redundancies across all sites
Conclusion
The Wilko case emphasises the necessity for businesses to take their consultation obligations seriously.
It serves as a critical reminder that meaningful consultation constitutes a legal requirement, even in the face of significant financial challenges.
In this particular instance, the Tribunal demonstrated limited sympathy for Wilko’s position. A more extended consultation period would have afforded employees a fair opportunity to engage in discussions regarding the forthcoming changes.
Due to their failures, Wilko now faces a financial liability associated with protective awards that exceeds £2 million. This is a warning to employers to meet their legal obligations, even when in financial difficulty.
Need Advice on Redundancy or Employment Law?
If you need clear, practical advice about your employment matters, don’t hesitate to contact us. A member of our trusted team will be able to advise on your legal position. Contact JFH Law today.
Please note that the information contained in this article was correct at the time of writing. There may have been updates to the law since the article was written which may affect the information and advice given therein.






