
Employee Relations part 2; Taking a Statement
If you employ staff, no doubt you will have had to conduct a grievance process or disciplinary investigation to resolve employee issues. Generally, such matters can be resolved internally without litigation.
However, every now and then you will face a disgruntled employee who decides to sue. During any employment tribunal hearing, your internal processes will be scrutinised. How you dealt with the matter and what evidence you obtained will make or break your defence.
Part of any internal investigation is likely to require the taking of statements from relevant employee witnesses. Here we set out when you should take a statement and give practical tips for taking those statements, to help you have the best chance of defending claims against you. Getting it right from the outset will save you time and money in the long run.
When to take a statement
If you have to investigate a grievance or disciplinary allegations, you will need to take a statement from potential witnesses.
If you have not yet decided whether to start disciplinary action against an employee and are still at the investigation stage, we would advise taking statements at an early stage to help you assess how to proceed. Taking statements early on means information will be fresh in an employee’s mind.
Another situation where you might want to take statements, is if you are a regulated profession and you have issues with self-employed contractors who work on your site. Whilst self-employed staff have no right to raise a grievance or undergo disciplinary processes, you may need staff statements to terminate their contract or report concerns to a regulator, such as the GDC or GMC.
How to take a statement
First, this is not a statement from the complainant or accused; this relates solely to statements from potential witnesses.
Here are our top four tips for taking a statement:
- Do not ask leading questions.
These are questions that tend to have a ‘yes/no’ answer and give no room for hearing the witness’ version of events. You also do not want to put words in the witness’ mouth.
- Try to keep your questions neutral
If the allegation is X touched Y’s bottom at the Christmas party, do not ask ‘leading questions’; such “I heard that X touched Y, that’s correct isn’t it?”.
We would suggest the following:
• You attended the Christmas party, what happened? Where were you sat? Who were you sat with? How long did you stay? How much alcohol was everyone drinking?
o This may result in relevant information being given straight away. If not, ask the next question.
• Did you see anything untoward happen during the party?
o Here you are not mentioning anyone’s name or the allegation.
• Did you see any interactions between X and Y? If so, what were they?
o This is narrowing it down, but again without saying the allegation.
• Did you see X touch Y’s bottom?
o Finally, to make certain this witness did or did not see anything, ask specifically about the incident.
- Hold a meeting with the witness
Sending an email saying ‘did you see this happen on this date?’, is not only a leading question but leaves little room for follow up questions. It also does not give you the opportunity to see the witness’ demeanour when answering questions. This could tell you a lot about the situation.
- If you cannot hold a meeting
If there is really no option to hold a meeting, even by Zoom, make sure any proforma questionnaire sent only asks open questions to begin with. Only use more detailed questions as set out in point 2 above, if the open questions do not deal with the situation in question. Obtain the open response first before asking direct questions.
If you would like advice or assistance with any internal disciplinary or grievance process, please call the team on 0207 388 1658 or email lawyers@jfhlaw.co.uk.
Please note that the information contained in this article was correct at the time of writing. There may have been updates to the law since the article was written which may affect the information and advice given therein.






